Girlfriend Wanted an Open Relationship, I Broke Up with Her – Now She Wants to Come Back
After being in a committed relationship for four years, this guy’s world was rocked when his girlfriend asked for an open relationship. Holding onto his monogamous values, he made the snap decision to break up with her. But after receiving a series of emotional texts and voice messages begging him to reconsider, he’s left wondering whether his breakup was too hasty.
However, things took a shocking turn when he learned that his ex had been cheating on him with a mutual friend’s cousin during the time she brought up the idea of an open relationship. Now, trust issues have added a whole new layer of complexity to the situation, leaving him questioning his decision even further. Was he right to walk away, or did he act too quickly without all the facts?
A man said his girlfriend of four years suddenly wanted an open relationship
The request came out of the blue and the man didn’t like her suggestion
This situation highlights the critical importance of understanding the boundaries and values that shape a relationship. For this guy, monogamy wasn’t just a preference—it was a deeply held belief about how relationships should function. When his girlfriend of four years suggested an open relationship, it felt like a betrayal of the trust they had built. To him, their relationship had always been grounded in certain expectations, and asking for an open relationship seemed to threaten the very foundation of their bond. While his girlfriend may have felt that she could bring it up after years of being together, he saw it as a fundamental difference in values—one that couldn’t be overlooked.
The decision to break up immediately wasn’t an easy one, but he acted on his gut feeling. He didn’t want to remain in a relationship that conflicted with his core beliefs. Additionally, in the weeks leading up to the conversation, he had already sensed emotional distance—his girlfriend had been distant and disengaged, which made him feel that their relationship wasn’t as solid as it had once been. For him, the open relationship request was only the final straw; the emotional disconnect and breakdown in communication were already signs that something was wrong. After four years together, the sudden realization that things weren’t right anymore hit him hard.
Initially, when he received her emotional texts and voicemails begging for another chance, he may have been conflicted. It’s only natural to feel a pull when someone expresses regret after a long-term relationship. But for him, going back didn’t seem feasible. The trust had been broken. Even if he wanted to forgive her, there was an underlying feeling that the damage to their bond couldn’t be undone. No amount of apologies or tears could restore the faith he once had in their relationship. He had already seen too much and felt too hurt to consider rekindling what was already fractured.
As if the situation wasn’t complicated enough, things took an even more painful turn when he began to have suspicions about his ex’s actions during the month she had been acting distant. A nagging feeling told him that something wasn’t right, and after confiding in mutual friends, the truth slowly came to light: she had been cheating on him. His worst fears were confirmed when he spoke to one of her closest friends, who revealed that she had been involved with a mutual friend’s cousin. This moment was a game-changer for him. The request for an open relationship wasn’t just a random thought—it had been a smokescreen, a cover for something that had already been happening. She had been stepping outside their relationship while asking for the “freedom” to explore others. This revelation hit him like a punch to the gut, validating his suspicions and making the breakup feel even more justified.
Determined to understand the full extent of the situation, he decided to take matters into his own hands. He reached out to the guy involved, arranging a face-to-face meeting to get some clarity. When they sat down, the guy was surprisingly sincere, expressing genuine remorse. He explained that he hadn’t known she was in a committed relationship until she had reached out to him, expressing a desire to get back with her boyfriend. What stood out to him was that this guy wasn’t trying to cover up his actions—he seemed truly sorry for what had happened. Even more surprisingly, he respected that he was now no longer part of the picture. In a strange twist, the guy seemed like a decent person. He apologized for his part in the affair and ended things with her as soon as he found out about her relationship. This conversation provided him with a sense of closure he hadn’t expected. It wasn’t just about his ex anymore; it was about understanding that she wasn’t the only one at fault here.
After the discussion with the other guy, he felt a renewed sense of empowerment. He now understood that his ex had been dishonest not only in her actions but also in her intentions. In hindsight, the open relationship request had seemed like nothing more than a convenient excuse for what she had already been doing behind his back. This realization helped solidify that he had made the right decision by ending things when he did. But, even with this newfound clarity, the emotional weight of the betrayal didn’t disappear. He could now walk away knowing that he hadn’t been wrong to break up with her, but the sting of what had happened still lingered.
There was still the temptation to send her a cutting note with her things—something sharp that would remind her of what she had lost. A part of him wanted to lash out, to make her feel the consequences of not only losing him but also losing someone else she had been involved with. But, in the end, he resisted. He realized that sending such a message wouldn’t bring him the peace he sought. Instead, he was learning that the best form of revenge was to simply move on and let her go. Blocking her on everything became his way of taking control, refusing to be dragged into her mess any longer. It wasn’t about punishing her—it was about protecting himself and his peace of mind.
Many people supported the man’s decision to break up with his girlfriend
In the end, the situation had come full circle. His ex wanted him back, but the reality of their relationship, scarred by deceit and a lack of respect, was no longer something he could return to. Though the emotional scars might take time to heal, the closure he now had made him more certain in his decision to move forward. He no longer looked back. His energy was now focused on the future, and that was where his attention would remain.
