AITA for Breastfeeding My Son Around My Father-in-Law Despite His Discomfort?
In the vulnerable weeks following childbirth, a 23-year-old mother finds herself at the center of an awkward and deeply personal standoff with her in-laws. While breastfeeding her infant in her own living room, she becomes the subject of passive-aggressive remarks and discomfort from her father-in-law, who equates her nursing to public indecency. Despite retreating to her room to breastfeed in the past, this time she remained downstairs—tired, alone, and simply responding to her baby’s hunger.
The scene quickly escalates when her in-laws walk in and object to her nursing openly, with her father-in-law muttering inappropriate comparisons and her mother-in-law demanding she “take it to her room.” Frozen and exposed, the young mother finds herself unsupported and second-guessing her natural, legal right to feed her child. But is she wrong for standing her ground, or are her in-laws crossing a boundary they have no right to police?
Breastfeeding, especially in public, is still frowned upon by some people
What this new mom didn’t expect is that she would get the same treatment in her own home
Breastfeeding Rights, Body Autonomy, and Generational Misunderstandings
This story is more than a case of in-law tension—it’s about the right to breastfeed, bodily autonomy, and the outdated perceptions that still haunt public and semi-public breastfeeding.
Breastfeeding is a Legal Right—Yes, Even in Front of In-Laws
In nearly every U.S. state (and many countries worldwide), breastfeeding in public or private spaces is legally protected. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, all 50 states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and the Virgin Islands have laws that explicitly allow women to breastfeed in any public or private location where they are otherwise authorized to be (NCSL).
This means that even if guests in your home—or extended family members—are uncomfortable, you are under no legal or moral obligation to remove yourself from shared living spaces to breastfeed.
Emotional Labor, Modesty Policing, and “The Male Gaze”
What makes this case uniquely upsetting is how discomfort is placed squarely on the mother for merely existing in a maternal role. The father-in-law’s comment, equating her nursing to “walking around with his junk out,” is not only juvenile, it’s deeply revealing about how female bodies—especially postpartum bodies—are policed and sexualized even in the most natural contexts.
This phenomenon, often referred to in feminist discourse as “modesty policing”, places the responsibility for someone else’s discomfort onto the woman’s body rather than their mindset. It’s not about nudity—it’s about power and control, and who is allowed to feel “comfortable” in shared space.
The FIL’s repeated glances, followed by his crude remark, further complicate the dynamic. It implies a gaze not of discomfort, but of inappropriate fixation masked as moral concern. Unfortunately, it’s not uncommon—many breastfeeding women report being sexualized even when simply feeding their infants.
Navigating In-Law Dynamics While Upholding Boundaries
It’s clear this young mother has been trying to keep the peace. She retreated to her room out of politeness in the past. She didn’t cause a scene when confronted. She remained respectful, even in the face of humiliating comments. But at what point does politeness start becoming self-erasure?
Family dynamics often make these moments more emotionally fraught. According to a University of Michigan survey, more than 60% of new moms feel pressure from in-laws about how to parent, particularly around feeding and appearance (Michigan Medicine).
In situations like this, the responsibility must fall on the partner—and in this case, the husband—to set and enforce boundaries. It’s a good sign that he offered her water and tried to calm things down, but proactively communicating to his parents that her right to breastfeed will be respected in the home is essential for long-term harmony.
The Psychological Toll on New Mothers
The impact of this kind of confrontation goes deeper than momentary embarrassment. Postpartum women are already vulnerable to anxiety, body image issues, and identity shifts. Being shamed or scrutinized while doing something as integral as feeding a baby can deeply undermine their confidence.
A 2021 study published in the Journal of Human Lactation found that external criticism or disapproval of public breastfeeding contributes significantly to women stopping earlier than planned, especially when shamed by family or friends. The same study notes that social support is the most significant predictor of successful breastfeeding continuation (Source).
Most readers sided with the new mom
It’s Not About Modesty, It’s About Respect
This story isn’t about whether the mother should have used a cover or gone upstairs—it’s about whether her comfort and her child’s needs deserve the same respect as her in-laws’ outdated views. The answer is a resounding yes.
Breastfeeding is not an exhibition. It is not a statement. It is not a challenge to decency. It is a biological, maternal, legally protected act. The discomfort others feel is not the breastfeeding mother’s burden to carry.
If anything, what this new mom needs isn’t a cover or a room to hide in—but a circle of support that recognizes and defends her right to care for her child in peace. And that support begins at home.
