When “Comfy Joggers” Were a Trap: Why I Grabbed My Turkey and Walked Out

You’ve got a tight‑knit friend group you’ve known for over a decade, and every year you all have a Friendsgiving — you usually bring the turkey (and maybe a side). This time, everyone agreed to a comfy jogger‑dress code, but on the day of the event you discovered that some of the girls (without telling you) privately decided to “dress up nicely.” That left you showing up super casual while the rest of the group looked dressed-up.

That secret dress‑code change hit you hard: not just because you felt judged, but because it felt like they talked about you instead of talking to you. You got hurt, angry, and decided to leave — and because you’d worked hard on that turkey and side, you took it with you. Now you’re wondering: was that petty… or understandable?

Look: potlucks and Friendsgivings are more than just food — they work on unspoken social rules, expectations, group norms. When those norms feel violated, things get messy. Let’s break down what was happening, what rules you might’ve broken — and whether your reaction is defensible.

🍽 Potluck and “Friendsgiving” Basics: What People Usually Expect

A potluck — or a casual Friendsgiving — works best when people agree on who brings what, dress code, vibe. According to etiquette guides, good “potluck behavior” means coordinating with the host or organizer: sign‑ups for dishes, awareness of what others are bringing, maybe even menus and balance (mains, sides, desserts). Rachel Wagner | Etiquette & Protocol+2baghrconsulting.com+2

The idea behind this: the potluck isn’t just about feeding people — it’s about sharing responsibility. Everyone does their part so no one’s stuck doing everything. fftcaters.com+1

And yes — there’s also unspoken social etiquette: if you bring a dish, you bring it to share. You’re contributing to the collective meal, and rarely is that dish considered your private property again once you walk in the door. Many advice articles say that taking leftovers home — especially the dish you brought — is often seen as “bad manners,” unless the host explicitly offers. Food Republic+1

So in a normal potluck scenario, walking out with the turkey you cooked would raise eyebrows. You’d risk being labeled selfish, ungrateful, or even rude.

But: Potlucks Are Also Social — Not Just Culinary. So When Norms Are Broken, People Feel Hurt.

The wrinkle in your story is not just the food — it’s the dress‑code drama and emotional dynamics. Here’s where things get complicated:

• You all agreed to “comfy joggers.” That was the expectation set for everyone.
• On the day of, some people privately changed the plan — told by some friends (not you) to dress up because you “always dress nice.”
• That felt like gossip behind your back, hidden resentments, and you felt insecure, judged, and sad.

In a group that’s meant to be comfortable and close — a chosen family — that kind of behind‑your‑back talk can sting more than clothes or turkey ever could. It becomes a betrayal of trust.

Social‑psychology wise, when group norms shift without transparency, people get excluded — emotionally or socially. You felt unsafe being your authentic self (in joggers), after they shamed your normal style. That violates the implicit contract of trust and acceptance.

In these contexts, some say leaving is a way of protecting your dignity.

So Was Taking the Food “Wrong”? Depends on Some Key Details

People who write about potluck etiquette suggest that if you bring food, you bring it to share — so leftovers generally belong to the host or the group. Food Republic+2Rachel Wagner | Etiquette & Protocol+2

Yet, there are exceptions or gray areas. For example:

• If the host doesn’t expect to eat it (e.g. dietary restrictions) or says “take it if you want.” Food Republic+1
• If the dish was brought in your own container, and you politely ask if you can take leftovers back. Some etiquette guides gently allow it — but with communication first. The Kitchn+1
• If you leave early — sometimes it’s considered more acceptable to take what you brought (or what remains) rather than waste it. But that depends heavily on mutual agreement or host consent.

In your scenario, the food was your own dish, but what seems missing is a conversation with the host before leaving. Also: people felt hurt because you left and took it — maybe they saw it as a double insult: you left (social snub) and also removed the gift (food).

Emotional Context Matters: Feeling Hurt, Betrayed, and Wanting to Protect Yourself

From what you told, you weren’t only upset about the dress‑code switch — you felt used. The vibe wasn’t safe anymore. The hidden group chat where people talked about your style? That’s harsh. It’s not just about how you looked — it’s about how they treated you.

Leaving a situation where you feel judged or excluded — that’s self‑preservation. And yes — people do sometimes choose to withdraw from social settings when they feel slighted. For some, leaving the event but leaving the food behind might be a softer “exit.” You instead left with the food — maybe because it symbolized more than leftovers: it was your effort, your dignity, your say that you matter.

That said — walking out with the food also felt like a statement: you weren’t just leaving the party, you were reclaiming your effort and rejecting the social slight. It might feel cathartic in the moment.

What Could’ve Been Done Differently (From Both Sides)

Looking back, there’s a few ways this could’ve played out better for both you and them:

• Direct conversation: If one of your friends was worried about how they’d look given your style, an honest chat with you — not behind your back — would’ve saved a lot of pain. Transparency prevents resentment.
• Clear host‑led guidelines: For potlucks/friendsgivings, having a clear sign‑up for dishes, dress‑code, vibe — especially if someone’s bringing a major item like turkey — helps avoid misunderstandings. That’s something etiquette experts recommend. Rachel Wagner | Etiquette & Protocol+1
• When you felt hurt — quick de‑escalation could help: Instead of leaving abruptly, maybe stepping aside, talking privately with someone, or packing up quietly and letting them know — that might’ve eased tension.
• If you leave with food — ask permission or at least signal intent: It softens the action and shows it’s not spite, but practicality.

So… Were You the Asshole? Maybe — but There’s Reason to Understand

If I were to answer the central question: Yes, you probably crossed a line — by leaving and taking the food. Social norms around potlucks lean toward sharing and leaving contributions behind. People rely on those dishes for dessert, seconds, or leftovers. Taking the food leaves others hungry or disappointed.

But here’s the thing: morality and “rules” don’t happen in a vacuum. Given the emotional punch — the gossip, betrayal, the implicit judgment — your reaction becomes more understandable. It was less about the food, more about respect and identity.

In real‑life social dynamics, there are times when “ought” and “feel” conflict. If the group had been honest, you might never have left. If they valued your presence more than their insecurities, maybe no turkey would’ve walked home with you.

So I’d say: YTA (because you took food home without group consensus) — but only partway. The root of the mess was their secret deal behind your back. What they did was unfair. You could’ve navigated it with better communication. But given the emotional sting … I get why you snapped.

Many people who read the woman’s story said she had every right to leave

---

What to Do Next (If You Care to Fix Things)

If you want to salvage the friendships (and I see why you might, since this is an old group):

• Reach out calmly. Don’t accuse — just say “I felt hurt when I found out about the dress‑code talk.”
• Ask for honesty — tell them you value their feelings, but you ask the same in return.
• If you still want to contribute a dish next time — set boundaries. “I’ll bring the turkey if we all agree on vibe and dress.”
• Be ready to walk away if the pattern repeats. Sometimes self‑respect > staying in bad dynamic.

If you don’t care to salvage — that’s okay too. Sometimes exiting is the lesson. You reminded yourself: you don’t have to shrink to make other people comfortable.